Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for AMC_MIRL

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 0.0003456483.655890.967311324237.4
Fissures 06.627341.3216864127.6667
Landmarks 0.64003110.04673.4002883931.5333
Singularities 0.8388717.867373.6333364240.7333
Average 34.3333


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 2.544291.609370.6108343.131132.1001739
02 0.001109110.002226440.003479719.75473e-050.0016481537
03 0.01328120.0160980.01905840.01042890.014618335
04 0.01292190.006665390.01849221.39229e-050.009290537
05 0.008968180.002074340.01007520.001320750.0056099436
06 0.0005991798.282e-050.0002235530.0004474770.00034564839
07 1.704484.629872.34473.626843.0613137
08 7.174920.02627282.856564.297093.6492641
09 0.01239090.001902340.002016830.01189340.007295334
10 0.1515390.1101930.2507280.003991870.12757739
11 0.5751050.2637980.01919810.7272870.41879237
12 0.02597450.003533110.001981970.02639650.015137335
13 0.0217823.029310.3486482.515051.5088542
14 0.8983413.055873.212980.8940751.9903938
15 0.1159860.01310890.002490320.1183370.065817636
16 0.2723380.03987760.03592510.2520960.15924739
17 0.373230.01606060.09120940.270550.18492741
18 2.501391.741321.68292.487932.1300539
19 0.0003646720.008846130.003135940.005182670.0043134937
20 1.736031.218231.998851.033111.4822739
21 4.302522.984192.112224.784143.6558937
22 5.094440.07110881.965923.263442.621940
23 4.68060.02378932.013892.608212.3489741
24 0.002867470.0006336640.001484120.001766440.0016309932
25 0.4859330.001276650.006300580.4562910.247139
26 0.000634560.001468050.001125360.001017790.0010633933
27 0.006165690.007694520.003744210.009550470.0069218932
28 2.335651.263980.5117622.851391.8034437
29 0.004646710.005188670.01003750.000242850.0049457135
30 2.709640.00198570.7564581.921391.3905639
Avg 1.258940.6718670.6965481.177020.96731137.4


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.06455893.761773.0380231
02 00017
03 0.001689190.0001989530.00058803529.5
04 00019
05 00.000590570.00021070535
06 0.02673460.01214590.017858636
07 0.2448452.966451.5102227
08 13.67810.0114675.5930838
09 00010
10 00018
11 0.1363720.01544840.055434320
12 00.003171470.0020917929
13 0.2442752.650951.0886437
14 1.852790.5827441.173516
15 0.007144720.001391530.0039970228
16 3.898030.9291621.6420534
17 2.548990.04503291.0168141
18 6.065460.3049832.5782722
19 0.00203760.0004995380.0011815936
20 0.4451044.410182.8968227
21 4.235427.750226.6273436
22 2.118680.01000321.0896440
23 12.77590.1687295.1928337
24 00015.5
25 5.192160.0002198261.9255340
26 0.0072661700.0021266518
27 0.008655560.001737220.0044959125
28 1.53285.506814.0859225
29 00016.5
30 0.2674140.00180340.10376336.5
Avg 1.845150.971191.3216827.6667


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 3.887813.3113.683916.982917.32530.97569219.81727.1575332
02 0.1968750.3290.3093750.5821110.78764602.109380.68076829
03 0.4148440.3850.4359370.9022840.93596203.977480.91878633
04 0.4617540.4835660.6646451.369790.91147407.150571.1372120
05 0.5250.630.5643751.027521.4330905.308911.2262536
06 0.3168750.2550.2254690.6086730.6576703.960310.64003132
07 2.459532.13.116955.04725.38301017.74625.1646431
08 2.2052.9193.90755.703416.246650.720.23545.9967638
09 0.5126950.4550.5605471.101021.1331803.693581.1167834
10 0.5597020.6447541.322292.267111.340980.468759.444051.7971321
11 1.254391.3090.989181.919333.104730.713.50882.4454234
12 0.7521290.7140.7521291.576841.5483304.953711.5611635
13 2.177731.56251.90432.971134.40759012.34283.7468238
14 4.76932.5553.493489.547495.32351.1757435.31787.4777429
15 0.9492191.6451.560942.844062.6971706.583922.761837
16 1.416021.152.656253.950433.50499011.65973.718835
17 1.757811.481.298832.844863.7054408.991643.1838339
18 2.877933.2482.105476.389724.616080.68359415.60125.5028930
19 0.6168750.8190.8371881.562831.5498803.684861.5568736
20 4.043162.4362.355867.497594.095050.63671916.68766.0685329
21 5.617355.64.147189.4408210.73921.5953719.555310.046730
22 2.445311.9393.671885.081665.5983016.30565.3709836
23 1.582032.653.017585.655724.31888012.98714.947237
24 0.4050510.5386180.3107241.089840.66243303.192410.91013318
25 1.869770.9590.7749222.348672.7025308.951242.5079137
26 0.3318750.270.2765620.5682380.85973902.651490.72564830
27 0.5820120.5110.5064261.183041.1478805.229961.1647633
28 4.100223.4093.28917.374487.148911.0216422.95027.1834432
29 0.3122730.3348720.4201490.7702730.80637601.859950.7858068
30 1.937892.2822.626564.392394.61552017.30314.5061937
Avg 1.711281.564141.726193.486713.310250.2652511.12543.4002831.5333


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 4.049516.762733.882767.347585.6151740
02 1.561131.537291.292231.805561.5488941
03 4.81464.7765.389984.199124.7945542
04 1.179731.080360.7592261.477251.1182438
05 0.03656752.232841.119281.201331.160342
06 3.624084.477563.251214.843234.0472242
07 5.575176.962894.199048.278386.2387141
08 0.0050568111.52015.493556.589866.041742
09 3.349083.045613.448132.93613.1921142
10 1.227091.154830.9331851.431691.1824439
11 4.22043.887782.663315.401084.032241
12 2.933932.302932.950462.221372.5859242
13 6.971760.004624273.690713.777213.7339642
14 6.552197.374085.466258.463716.9649839
15 0.04811724.249021.914862.605572.2602241
16 08.912653.700366.661065.1807140
17 0.0001602034.644232.507762.619722.5637442
18 6.734868.966296.061999.672757.8673741
19 08.185094.579944.860964.7204542
20 6.264246.775165.075198.014986.5450940
21 2.938124.630391.405656.264733.8351936
22 0.0121833.85241.84762.237592.042641
23 07.27344.281663.382233.8319540
24 0.9742050.9981880.8394031.137220.98831339
25 0.03463921.568131.036620.6411240.83887141
26 3.207363.222142.609153.821693.2154242
27 3.06263.576433.102293.554563.3284242
28 6.086897.92195.029119.127367.0782441
29 1.052371.055160.9832411.124721.0539839
30 0.0005200262.6041.211831.572061.3919542
Avg 2.550554.518473.02424.242393.633340.7333


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.