Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for Lyon FFD

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 00.1108540.0059655583620.7167
Fissures 05.099130.50120643218.8667
Landmarks 0.06995789.920221.51774142922.9667
Singularities 01.296260.043368912.53417.45
Average 20


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.001511420.009741043.51136e-050.009391510.005645217
02 0000014.5
03 0.001735520.0006924830.0006770650.001757180.0012381928
04 0.016531800.013778900.006869136
05 0000015.5
06 0000018
07 0.0114330.004493320.00229410.01243420.0080991119
08 0.00249373000.002307950.0012722722
09 0.0007508230.0002438480.0003509590.0006372380.00050418225
10 0.02390090.0009079090.01914390.002022360.010451432
11 0.01650418.77057e-0500.01454030.0082121712
12 0000014.5
13 00.002321950.0003490750.001848240.0011455925
14 0.187840.03600380.0278040.1836670.11085426
15 5.02393e-05004.72381e-052.58815e-0522
16 0.00105620.0007952100.001625070.00092914118
17 0000010
18 0.01230240.00141650.001161690.01152150.0068766516
19 0000018
20 0.0002468360.001954250.001296850.0009304440.00109620
21 0.004399090.001532750.001476050.00419380.0030135615
22 0.0003952250.002159050.001810850.0007169110.00124228
23 0000011
24 0.002512540.0004096420.001192220.001445920.0013242230
25 0000016
26 0.00332147000.002789220.0016064736
27 0.00534063000.004988550.0027045430
28 0.0004863980.0067870200.006559240.0036300419
29 0.002888520.001699890.0047318600.0022266532
30 0000016
Avg 0.00985670.002374880.002536750.00878080.0059655520.7167


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 00.04044620.032528615
02 00017
03 00014.5
04 00019
05 00017
06 00.00910940.0055423230.5
07 0.002999981.590250.74097418
08 0.09645860.07032170.080996323
09 00010
10 00018
11 0.1294230.002896570.044735219
12 00013.5
13 0.1565120.1244960.14527929
14 5.719380.03759642.680515
15 00.002087290.00114226
16 0.0404640.09376860.08096923
17 0.078102800.03031144
18 1.447961.303491.360517
19 00013
20 0.06349051.358840.86443812
21 6.609834.389945.0991332
22 0.0011123300.00056951519
23 0.08488960.1687290.13531822
24 00015.5
25 00015.5
26 0.011625900.0034026332
27 0.002847227.55314e-050.0011807423
28 0.127685.73273.7286623
29 00016.5
30 00014
Avg 0.4857590.4974920.50120618.8667


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 1.420551.6591.386562.251773.757015.74373.0194422
02 0.2601560.2380.2390630.501930.65901502.108340.57733124
03 0.1898440.2450.281250.5573060.61469601.721020.58542725
04 0.7905780.7253490.4897391.663561.0515307.771231.3529723
05 0.09843750.0980.1050.1572990.35274401.162470.25306727
06 0.2071880.1350.1401560.3343350.49796801.729940.4390627
07 0.8198441.260.8585161.789172.36602011.94282.059718
08 0.750.6370.54750.9213551.688707.751.3357226
09 0.3554690.3220.2871090.5454090.9354403.75630.73652428
10 0.769590.8417630.8325562.02711.24632010.26161.6308820
11 0.6952930.7070.5734380.9204411.8516012.77021.3395724
12 0.1163090.0980.1705860.2723660.37025902.10.32620724
13 0.5468750.63750.5566411.348291.2348309.860861.2870229
14 1.522971.7221.055392.054323.87741017.3232.9476321
15 0.3515620.3290.33750.6528810.85597305.165190.76661325
16 0.5078120.750.4296871.125221.5547705.187231.3485923
17 0.4492170.540.3808580.8438211.3678506.156891.06824
18 1.743161.471.244142.363773.5741017.79882.9689323
19 0.2643750.2730.3671880.5877840.79612702.738790.68362229
20 1.20341.2881.037852.513332.1534409.504712.3621822
21 5.229695.657144.059415.6753213.63150.755.31689.9202228
22 0.6093750.5670.6171881.250311.2636207.508961.2577627
23 0.31250.350.3222660.8267280.89689402.856110.86391620
24 0.3495650.5590720.4438921.115480.81066703.170350.98731819
25 0.04265630.0280.03554690.05679470.08604602.118290.069957815
26 0.221250.1050.2005080.3649690.51372502.464620.44529719
27 0.2040820.2590.2418750.5195570.61908202.194680.5713121
28 1.436191.8831.287363.676262.77202021.43953.169325
29 0.4485370.4185910.4598931.020040.84973503.329990.94676614
30 0.05605470.1120.08808590.1081310.31166401.800690.21193317
Avg 0.7324180.7971470.6358921.268171.752020.02333338.491771.5177422.9667


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0000013
02 0000015.5
03 0000016.5
04 0000015.5
05 0000016
06 0000017.5
07 6.23763e-059.53071e-0500.0001562457.81223e-0524
08 0000015
09 0000015
10 0000015
11 0000014
12 0000017.5
13 0000015
14 0.00185223000.001843920.00092196223
15 0000015.5
16 0000016.5
17 0000016
18 0.000442064000.0004354090.00021770424
19 0000016
20 0000012.5
21 1.267531.3217302.592531.2962634
22 0000014.5
23 0000016
24 0000015.5
25 0000015
26 0000017.5
27 0000016.5
28 00.006641780.0071763300.0035881630
29 0000015.5
30 0000016
Avg 0.04232960.04428220.0002392110.08649890.043368917.45


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.