Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for NParBR

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 06.848751.9777314.54134.5833
Fissures 013.58722.55263134231.3167
Landmarks 0.17643113.54895.03523253834.8
Singularities 6.07183e-061.098250.125658293934.8333
Average 33.8833


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 7.216566.453565.872927.494956.8487541
02 0000014.5
03 0.004663930.3226990.0009653530.3020940.15759740
04 0.01169980.00101520.010819400.0054501233
05 05.9009e-0505.56994e-052.86839e-0533
06 0000018
07 3.372357.318032.164397.551975.268441
08 1.762163.729810.4363824.525632.7161240
09 0.2159210.5183350.1175840.574610.36469639
10 4.458534.249227.356571.272564.3362641
11 4.137892.598281.770524.574743.3656141
12 1.035270.3927980.1041331.246990.7248940
13 0.01480760.006998170.00463880.01645850.01095734
14 5.273295.147081.716668.172455.2090940
15 00.00034432500.0003054440.00016718926
16 0.013216000.01196040.0067862230
17 0.004256680.0014672500.005317320.002793533
18 6.413166.788174.066988.592516.5993940
19 0000018
20 4.540094.932943.789685.489974.7349241
21 5.408535.953744.783866.317115.6766439
22 2.339642.143840.8469943.499752.2442239
23 0.009009640.0090436500.01600720.0090266133
24 1.490681.248012.726980.07247881.3539539
25 0000016
26 0.001681585.78873e-0500.001465220.00084502832
27 0.04260980.05913990.05369290.04840240.050804536
28 5.009426.015732.742977.700345.5107841
29 3.777413.135196.951270.1312193.4204941
30 0.9706170.4363090.234471.108790.71313338
Avg 1.917452.048731.525082.290941.9777334.5833


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 1.053152.475552.1971129
02 00017
03 0.03772520.003879580.012716236
04 0.003211100.0014871838
05 00017
06 0.023589400.0092371934
07 6.730572.237994.641833
08 1.718853.252762.6262933
09 0.0002063730.187550.12129735
10 0.70662900.44565540
11 6.625351.059072.8996734
12 3.473124.246113.9829638
13 2.266490.1069041.5088138
14 9.8144416.868313.587239
15 00.02382990.013037931
16 00.06819540.051820219
17 0.5893217.326854.7120442
18 14.21255.095128.6931736
19 00013
20 15.11236.523719.8017437
21 3.123722.089112.4196426
22 0.02621931.495980.74346136
23 7.597623.065244.8714535
24 00015.5
25 00.0003297380.00020746332
26 0.010172600.002977329.5
27 0.01232.616791.5782538
28 2.5766215.170910.667934
29 00016.5
30 2.540990.0220570.98899538
Avg 2.60852.464542.5526331.3167


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 4.669454.7533.520787.013229.954791.5290220.97058.5134233
02 0.281250.3360.3164060.6333920.81458701.721020.72036630
03 1.792971.5821.624223.042613.6883707.4933.3590337
04 1.923973.089451.077436.365321.973740.468758.784954.1367636
05 0.0918750.0560.0656250.1029410.2529201.679680.17643125
06 0.4265620.90.391.21161.384504.701781.3222538
07 6.589695.4113.859458.8727912.06440.726.104110.379936
08 2.8954.1441.70253.913477.518030.719.05975.8599337
09 1.524412.2681.620123.117894.39240.6835949.918493.742437
10 3.260265.910251.7840511.76933.281890.89410816.1957.4622437
11 2.824183.3391.956863.962377.482130.717.66855.5418438
12 3.582312.242.97754.988456.790291.0446213.58195.9794738
13 1.210941.20.9082032.101272.5452407.173582.3410136
14 9.792424.9634.6223412.929914.19331.6888929.863613.548937
15 0.506250.7140.5554690.9065821.602306.377991.2961935
16 0.5371090.950.4785161.102071.88903010.04761.5112926
17 1.015621.640.732422.359232.70261010.4662.4737
18 7.922854.0672.809577.8742512.85181.3671923.992910.36336
19 0.3451560.3290.3157810.7150660.82226802.504890.76437931
20 6.959348.5262.8015612.079112.59163.0759823.868212.294336
21 7.811624.364294.117938.372113.26722.3723424.459210.93433
22 4.109382.5924.620056.915330.7812510.99045.905437
23 0.4296870.7250.3222660.9652381.5009205.094471.2491529
24 3.301453.961231.170778.145112.073940.48828111.39035.5924637
25 0.3910160.2450.4123440.7026280.8951405.915610.78925834
26 0.4494140.7650.3941021.038061.4388603.436691.2544935
27 1.730923.711.602423.721685.8421011.6994.824336
28 4.896455.7333.490027.5783611.05231.5854825.94839.3090434
29 2.95243.697551.101477.762671.739270.48828113.93155.171238
30 1.913871.6732.602544.316074.17588011.66244.2445835
Avg 2.871262.796061.711094.742765.256570.61892612.895.0352334.8


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.1107220.1855680.0003462120.3074770.15391231
02 00.0010190600.00104630.00052315233
03 0.0631730.01932730.009234760.07156680.040400838
04 0.1893820.2040360.295590.101310.1984537
05 00.022441700.02296480.011482437
06 0.04332850.1518740.03641710.1578690.097143239
07 0.1092210.07708980.002734280.1849810.093857432
08 0.07126070.0602220.0003099520.1306380.065473837
09 0.01712040.002121270.001665120.01705920.0093621836
10 1.451510.879831.548030.6484661.0982538
11 0.08258560.1154320.001678250.2006630.10117136
12 0.008892920.0009405780.0004016140.00861240.0045070137
13 0.005721050.0015028900.007521540.0037607733
14 0.1018260.1307760.08295320.1497780.11636632
15 0.01873390.024169300.04319210.02159634
16 0.03568650.08163880.01213530.112660.062397436
17 0.02731470.0081908800.03351630.016758135
18 0.08283170.08865890.001292620.1702860.085789230
19 0.000511793000.0004332710.00021663532
20 0.1556520.2038760.03466160.329660.18216134
21 0.1833380.1467965.03662e-050.3278840.16396729
22 0.07742720.07327570.02525040.1252140.075232236
23 0.08387040.01939150.03961410.0601860.049900137
24 0.3535570.759930.3871390.7980920.59261538
25 01.15776e-0501.21437e-056.07183e-0630
26 0.01788020.01769320.003870960.03168550.017778238
27 0.05883840.1288830.002060960.1880880.095074636
28 0.1072930.090555800.1965020.098250932
29 0.1452090.4193650.1908250.4159430.30338438
30 0.01576080.004913170.005940720.01398580.0099632834
Avg 0.1206220.1306510.08940670.161910.12565834.8333


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.