Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for Oxford Elastic

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 7.03649e-051.332310.225455234035.4167
Fissures 0.057335524.85748.30217244239.75
Landmarks 1.7231142.066814.5089384240.25
Singularities 01.274660.130959153831.8167
Average 36.8083


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.8341730.4741140.9063720.4913250.65541736.5
02 0.18065.0503e-0500.1715090.093247539
03 0.04167220.001258693.93865e-050.04186670.022103737
04 0.02982090.007292580.033010600.016625740
05 0.009054530.02481900.03190830.016792638
06 0.000137731000.0001282567.03649e-0538
07 0.4494240.5346260.9500590.1533290.49056233
08 0.06205180.02391490.03213240.05246630.043493535
09 0.00027850.03301640.001983710.02859880.016391537
10 0.2069990.1049250.2918940.000603730.14727140
11 0.06515340.04652090.06333430.05010810.055787226
12 0.1054940.01308710.008966860.1049390.060818936
13 0.0007500020.007454748.65632e-050.007469120.004049632
14 0.4388230.5351260.7278320.2864440.487833
15 1.033131.127441.477060.7686671.0790340
16 0.2109610.089934800.2666690.1519838
17 00.00021735800.0002167070.0001139323
18 0.5225690.6886131.072630.2366960.60529935
19 0.152210.0189560.05597660.1145290.089715638
20 0.3161260.3918180.6830650.0869730.35379436
21 1.881980.7651632.306680.6509721.3323134
22 0.01368230.03243090.0003354810.04249570.022819230
23 0.02162790.0006780410.0004478870.01932820.011193134
24 0.01135390.003171450.01152740.00223770.0067179435
25 0.06345520.002015810.0001540490.06167040.033381336
26 0.0596726000.05021520.028960538
27 0.4844860.05790340.08336380.427530.27271939
28 0.9424260.2455940.5172690.6552030.59504835
29 0.01153780.007527060.0192792.3839e-050.0093015536
30 0.03319560.08974620.09152310.03598560.060849135
Avg 0.2727610.177580.3111670.1613370.22545535.4167


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 8.8546727.241923.642540.5
02 0.3289871.127870.83026939
03 9.742120.5215552.9289342
04 00.1782120.095675341
05 23.593414.777820.448142
06 0.0125810.295550.18474440
07 5.673214.84559.9377739
08 21.12526.739712.614941
09 8.331270.3846973.1949541
10 01.81830.67153941
11 8.293323.5818.525241
12 9.417243.955785.8150541
13 3.759210.1948632.5086841
14 7.4400614.482211.206535
15 0.5299713.2597.4943140
16 5.0984619.785216.258641
17 0.5041180.4233090.45467140
18 13.449532.294224.857441
19 1.0210.8083770.90266241
20 1.774162.889482.4637924
21 4.9959811.70669.5627738
22 0.3460941.900111.1044541
23 15.32268.9988711.518939
24 0.40294100.0737840
25 0.04997840.9789930.6344939
26 0.1366040.04449790.071455339
27 12.267812.824612.602541
28 26.682922.072923.721242
29 0.26778100.057335540
30 6.564935.969724.682142
Avg 6.532879.136668.3021739.75


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 8.924326.78912.315942.001225.48024.7180266.345233.575540.5
02 1.46254.3891.603125.690824.657260.712.40845.1947139
03 5.069532.7022.770315.773188.766470.70312517.33547.2398939
04 3.218286.035621.672119.177815.893141.2077316.53077.5109640
05 4.488758.7644.1868711.740111.54050.6562520.277411.642342
06 0.9201560.7950.6581251.899561.6238603.951981.7231139
07 6.2571121.8687.896835.926316.9515055.067526.079641
08 3.819.7516.04516.362210.97030.7523.644313.450541
09 4.183595.4396.9863311.49469.667121.6812219.994610.599140
10 4.288719.107163.0363813.57678.812061.2077320.010811.158841
11 3.5409815.9254.2506123.085412.08212.8671936.973717.79342
12 4.908222.9543.124828.411256.46169018.98147.3389941
13 1.689453.03751.103524.692963.53148012.65174.0657640
14 9.8926226.3767.4211341.310619.73331.5082256.859730.737741
15 9.0492221.7284.4367232.357718.65140.742.914724.682241
16 1.660165.6252.792977.663066.933680.97656217.63577.2837841
17 1.455071.641.474613.101993.46426010.343.206640
18 5.9267625.8867.0888736.131921.73476.4035254.484528.933341
19 6.851725.5516.0365613.65799.759560.734.51911.864741
20 8.0353918.8655.2529330.679111.87971.4531552.949322.783341
21 10.795833.771416.062159.294328.55853.2263105.08542.066838
22 3.754.0322.6256.500647.181160.719.16876.8817339
23 1.474614.752.148447.292144.83129015.12665.9878938
24 4.30024.697573.5400410.47463.819930.91477514.80217.6765939
25 4.40077.0283.6826611.15798.786790.99771423.139510.090940
26 1.175391.0050.8227732.56511.7401605.265592.1196339
27 5.8503513.0695.6538319.870313.47854.2383134.683116.546641
28 7.7390625.62710.060839.904923.14715.1621154.731730.791841
29 3.111374.353343.258999.050893.583450.91477516.74446.6986240
30 6.2380912.78210.746524.595814.68961.063645.38719.543741
Avg 4.815611.14484.9584918.181410.9471.4483430.933714.508940.25


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.8981530.8645231.345090.41240.87874736.5
02 0.005580020.00259270.003309740.004783110.0040464234
03 0.01944032.99338e-0500.01871830.0093591435
04 0.06428760.01799850.06879860.002486880.035642736
05 0.003693830.02139390.008287620.01721280.012750238
06 0000017.5
07 0.3021760.6893420.9178060.05679490.48730136
08 0.01872260.01451350.007630730.02540140.01651632
09 0.003392090.01526460.003793390.01527280.009533137
10 0.0648460.02921150.08268050.002971830.042826235
11 0.09121390.03897960.06483060.05848770.061659133
12 0.005248690.002912760.004596250.003324480.0039603636
13 0000015
14 0.2638020.1244090.2635180.1240680.19379334
15 0.01220420.01946350.008267940.02378570.016026832
16 0000016.5
17 0000016
18 0.3224860.1889930.4408110.06865860.25473533
19 0.02222170.002047830.005842160.01533220.010587238
20 0.2239260.1579570.1988110.1765150.18766335
21 1.677350.9176891.615070.9342441.2746633
22 0.009363090.01703510.01241760.01442140.013419533
23 0000016
24 0.03891220.001829170.03415234.2198e-050.017097236
25 0.005081610.008822160.008573420.005513220.0070433236
26 0.000451236000.0004101680.00020508435
27 0.02344230.005847550.01489610.0137840.0143435
28 0.5755240.1367410.2186450.4583050.33847535
29 0.02807960.004126080.028519100.014259535
30 0.0203010.02744060.01791530.03031820.024116735
Avg 0.1566630.1103050.1791420.08277510.13095931.8167


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.