Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for Oxford Flow Discontinuity Preserving

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 00.1496290.01313493724.3333
Fissures 016.06451.945134.53921.3
Landmarks 0.01818729.531971.87494113622.4
Singularities 01.294330.16344117.53934.3833
Average 25.6042


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.05932710.097523400.1293130.078250327
02 0000014.5
03 7.27304e-05007.18436e-053.7679e-0522
04 0.01473820.001152670.013452400.0067815435
05 2.19611e-050.017061400.015980.0083602837
06 3.95406e-05003.68263e-052.01724e-0536
07 0.02262110.03227790.001341380.0462570.027276623
08 0.01154490.011680100.02076410.011610629
09 0.0002711960.0002324710.0002793190.0002290570.00025217421
10 0.02698620.01520870.039873300.020095236
11 0.3010250.00022341600.2606570.14962930
12 0000014.5
13 00.0001636400.0001502558.05226e-0513
14 0.02577590.03705330.01635260.04398510.031514722
15 00.0047753800.004182160.0023258235
16 00.0049218500.004215630.0023981824
17 00.0093512100.009332830.0049030735
18 0.03350420.01841020.0006515470.0458050.025989623
19 0000018
20 0.005424960.0005020976.38243e-050.005328330.0029769522
21 0.01775830.00618540.0005132990.02021850.012072419
22 0.0007620180.0020435200.00260690.001385419
23 0.000486758000.0004318840.00024422223
24 0.0022164.78382e-050.0002318690.001692070.00098852722
25 00.005050580.005344800.0024727235
26 2.04802e-05001.72524e-059.94919e-0623
27 0.001083629.06151e-0600.001007320.00055171226
28 0.001942180.0055638400.006663930.0037477420
29 9.0753e-051.10991e-059.62864e-0504.63763e-0520
30 0000016
Avg 0.01752380.008981630.002606690.02063150.01313424.3333


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 10.176717.497616.064538
02 00017
03 00014.5
04 00019
05 00017
06 00.006072940.003694885.5
07 4.918122.478333.7837732
08 2.46718.009775.7460839
09 00.002597020.001678628
10 00018
11 17.56940.7701676.3251838
12 00013.5
13 0.08191270.05277540.0716912
14 13.91171.997177.5392830
15 00.0001739419.5167e-0516.5
16 0.2292960.008524420.061536520
17 0.1278050.004503290.05235618
18 9.76950.6660264.2585729
19 0.00015673906.95051e-0528
20 6.39135.554025.8735932
21 0.1551121.243320.89566920
22 00.00083360.00040679617.5
23 0.08488963.79642.3173231
24 00015.5
25 00015.5
26 0.0058129400.0017013210.5
27 0004.5
28 0.1093958.27715.3567829
29 00016.5
30 00014
Avg 2.199941.678851.9451321.3


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 2.501258.0572.310949.889569.1884034.99349.5319735
02 0.2953120.2030.3445310.6596370.69069501.721020.67454528
03 0.1898440.0840.1335940.3266560.35052901.570840.33835411
04 0.8955222.596931.049444.664721.7616509.881653.1915234
05 0.00656250.0070.01312500.037116701.162470.018187219
06 0.1706250.090.146250.3615810.36266501.619050.36227521
07 1.763442.9611.036414.342033.82815029.71254.0416729
08 0.963.0311.14752.044835.11777023.33.7042236
09 0.2392580.2240.2324220.4026440.70181503.071940.54923818
10 1.357284.074491.700097.651082.2786018.12314.9247535
11 0.881661.2740.5375980.6597113.34408019.45391.8879229
12 0.02326170.0350.02326170.03446180.10275901.300950.072025120
13 0.3320310.38750.3710940.8390960.8042409.860860.82027313
14 3.146132.521.38276.111874.32933025.12565.2384227
15 0.3023440.280.2953120.5983010.67731605.301870.64254917
16 0.468750.3750.3710940.6036531.2734104.739460.95192614
17 0.4199210.520.2929680.5307811.5988608.118331.0114822
18 2.132812.451.052733.742194.13554021.7573.9388628
19 0.176250.1890.2350.4306020.54739302.191910.48432618
20 0.9869142.2191.101523.526412.28958020.41063.0069425
21 1.038621.628570.7972542.196752.82433011.71082.5137415
22 0.4140620.4760.4843751.089020.99338406.096821.0354617
23 0.3417970.4750.2148440.8109460.98603802.856110.90374521
24 0.41060.4636210.371761.022890.71530803.011530.89356717
25 0.09242190.0560.09953130.2323070.13749202.45020.1896422
26 0.1521090.1650.08988280.3650040.35398102.154110.35905212
27 0.1889650.210.1814060.4588840.50400501.829380.48234719
28 1.332011.6031.101333.251052.48362022.14422.8194722
29 0.7040330.4953320.3406611.535460.53891107.979171.1067122
30 0.1441410.2380.3123050.413820.6866803.323590.55297926
Avg 0.7355981.246280.5923641.959861.78812010.23241.8749422.4


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 1.185351.068871.469160.7671041.1181338
02 0.008805160.0030433100.01169440.0058472135
03 0.02934920.007623140.004653660.0314770.018065336
04 0.02094520.009397420.01326840.01432990.013799135
05 00.1034875.79554e-050.1058410.052949539
06 00.0001873846.19338e-050.0001238689.29007e-0536
07 0.1477450.9195230.3742710.6592740.51677237
08 0.05730020.05575950.02698060.08600450.056492536
09 0.02798190.001364440.003451540.02497680.014214238
10 0.2610510.3934660.4455010.2402480.34287537
11 0.419380.1262110.05692830.4500750.25350237
12 1.24377e-0501.1156e-0505.57798e-0635
13 0.05886660.105260.005211340.1556420.080426734
14 0.2115412.367451.330151.258511.2943337
15 0.02407160.01524700.03884950.019424833
16 0.02292590.1414660.04147740.1421830.091830237
17 0.055110.2753040.0006459220.3526740.1766638
18 0.2419610.5070340.2150920.5378940.37649336
19 0.006025950.0004846944.19294e-050.005618540.0028302436
20 0.4455660.3378290.5805880.1920990.38634338
21 0.02017740.03358730.006295780.04827610.027285928
22 0.009186840.007383530.001775420.01469140.0082333932
23 0.00014688300.00013899706.94987e-0532
24 0.000102490.0007292760.00094242200.00047121132
25 6.38393e-050.002222910.002295159.71493e-050.0011961533
26 0000017.5
27 0.0002325210.0026821800.002999620.0014998133
28 0.07101690.01871080.001511680.08400630.04275931
29 0.001153570.0001753590.001106967.14167e-050.00058918832
30 08.71129e-0509.31148e-054.65574e-0533
Avg 0.1108690.2168190.1527210.1741620.16344134.3833


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.