Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Initial Phase Results

These are the results for teams from the initial phase before and during the MICCAI workshop on 24th September 2010. Result tables are divided between the first 20 datasets (Table 1) which were registered by participants in their own facilities, and the last 10 datasets (Table 2) which were (mainly) registered on the morning of the workshop (see Table 2 for details). These results tables will remain static. From this point forward all results on the main results page will be based on all 30 datasets combined.

For more information about how scores and ranks are computed please see here.

Click on a team name for more detailed results for that team.

Table 1: Results for datasets 01-20

Registered by participants in their own facilities prior to the MICCAI workshop.
Lung Boundaries Fissures Landmarks Folding Overall
Team Name Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Rank Placed Method Type
picsl gsyn 0.006.370.039.520.663.200.0013.058.031Fully Auto
Nifty Reggers 0.007.620.2712.300.757.250.0012.529.922Fully Auto
Iowa sstvd ssvmd Laplacian 0.0012.050.0810.970.796.850.0013.2210.773Fully Auto
IMI Lübeck Diffeomorph 0.0111.850.229.820.898.220.0014.3211.054Fully Auto
Iowa sstvd ssvmd 0.0114.450.1512.120.889.800.0013.3012.415Fully Auto
CMS 0.0011.600.4714.100.9112.600.0012.5212.706Fully Auto
elastix 0.0011.150.5013.620.997.270.0220.4713.137Fully Auto
Philips Research 0.0112.550.5615.071.2412.100.0013.6213.338Fully Auto
Asclepios1 0.0112.021.3815.972.4713.670.0012.5213.559Fully Auto
Iowa sstvd 0.0113.950.3816.521.0712.050.0013.3013.9510Fully Auto
picsl exp 0.006.970.5314.351.2914.820.0019.7713.9811Fully Auto
MGH 0.0012.600.2613.271.4018.450.0012.5214.2112Semi Auto(2)
Robust TreeReg Leuven 0.0012.870.4714.621.4319.350.0014.1015.2313Fully Auto
Lyon FFD 0.0015.020.3013.701.3519.000.0014.2215.4814Fully Auto
Spline MIRIT Leuven 0.0013.100.4915.071.4820.290.0014.1215.6515Fully Auto
ISI@UMCU 0.1025.500.4211.601.128.620.0018.7716.1216Fully Auto
Asclepios2 0.2924.550.3613.321.1317.100.0012.5216.8717Fully Auto
HUJI CASMIP uniform 3.1425.504.1816.528.6814.120.0012.5217.1618Fully Auto
drop 0.0012.522.4822.923.0322.300.0012.5217.5619Fully Auto
DIKU 0.0419.070.9918.042.1922.200.0013.3018.1520Fully Auto
IMI Lübeck Feature based 0.0010.070.8321.872.0825.200.0016.9018.5121Fully Auto
PVG 0.0922.600.5417.821.1010.370.0924.5518.8322Fully Auto
HUJI CASMIP curvelets 3.3126.154.4518.328.9218.600.0012.5218.9023Fully Auto
MIC + Fraunhofer MEVIS Lübeck 0.0713.251.9824.422.7025.450.0012.5218.9124Fully Auto
3DSlicer 0.0320.002.0522.023.0021.570.0013.7719.3425Fully Auto
Oxford Flow Discontinuity Preserving 0.0119.102.4819.072.2617.000.2429.6021.1926Fully Auto
Lyon Demons 0.0925.950.6012.801.9421.500.1425.8221.5127Fully Auto
ICG LBI Graz Anisotropic Optical Flow 0.0117.772.8719.504.5618.173.0331.6721.7828Fully Auto
HUJI CASMIP gradient 3.1726.554.1024.059.0126.050.0012.5222.2929Fully Auto
Palreg 1.2626.352.9020.904.4826.900.1115.3022.3630Fully Auto
ICG LBI Graz Optical Flow 0.1323.804.4422.477.1327.551.0231.4026.3031Fully Auto
Slicer3 Demon 0.0521.352.3427.573.6423.623.2133.2026.4332Fully Auto
Romeo 3.9530.056.3628.8010.1931.050.0021.2227.7833Fully Auto
Oxford Elastic Reg 0.6030.657.1931.8511.6532.650.9930.7031.4634Semi Auto(10)
Team Name Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Rank Placed Method Type
Lung Boundaries Fissures Landmarks Folding Overall

Table 2: Results for datasets 21-30

Registered by participants for the workshop at MICCAI on 24th Sept 2010. Most calculations were carried out during the morning of the workshop, the remainder were carried out within the week following (see column "During Workshop"). Calculations carried out during the workshop were either done on laptops on site at the workshop, or else using remotely located hardware - see column "On Site"
Lung Boundaries Fissures Landmarks Folding Overall
Team Name Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Rank Placed Method Type During Workshop On Site
CMS 0.006.050.116.250.592.340.008.395.761Fully AutoYesNo
picsl gsyn 0.005.700.165.900.654.050.008.396.012Fully AutoYesNo
elastix 0.009.100.467.650.773.200.0011.057.753Fully AutoYesYes
IMI Lübeck Diffeomorph 0.008.050.617.851.065.700.009.897.874Fully AutoYesNo
Nifty Reggers 0.007.050.268.000.888.390.008.397.965Fully AutoYesYes
Philips Research 0.007.250.5810.351.039.000.008.398.756Fully AutoYesYes
Iowa sstvd ssvmd Laplacian 0.217.350.5211.705.048.100.008.398.887Fully AutoYesNo
ISI@UMCU 0.0315.750.327.750.723.900.008.398.958Fully AutoYesNo
picsl exp 0.007.100.258.451.039.700.0012.759.509Fully AutoNoNo
Asclepios1 0.008.600.9512.152.0212.300.008.3910.3610Fully AutoYesYes
Spline MIRIT Leuven 0.0011.850.879.891.4413.500.008.3910.9111Fully AutoYesNo
Robust TreeReg Leuven 0.0011.950.6110.201.3213.300.008.3910.9612Fully AutoYesNo
Lyon FFD 0.0011.800.8912.201.8411.000.1210.3511.3313Fully AutoYesNo
Asclepios2 0.0211.800.4611.701.3014.100.008.3911.5014Fully AutoYesYes
MGH 0.0612.101.6811.154.5113.401.629.7011.5815Semi Auto(2)YesYes
DROP 0.007.702.2315.402.3417.000.008.3912.1216Fully AutoYesYes
Oxford Flow Discontinuity Preserving 0.0011.800.8510.001.0810.300.0016.6512.1817Fully AutoYesYes
DIKU 0.0514.751.2612.502.1415.800.008.3912.8618Fully AutoNoNo
ICG LBI Graz Anisotropic Optical Flow 0.0414.654.9416.506.5217.792.1619.4017.0819Fully AutoNoNo
PVG 1.9319.600.6314.402.6117.101.4519.4017.6220Fully AutoNoNo
Team Name Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Score Avg Rank Avg Rank Placed Method Type During Workshop On Site
Lung Boundaries Fissures Landmarks Folding Overall


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.