Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for Oxford Elastic Reg

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 03.232610.603545163430.65
Fissures 0.092700925.49017.19982243431.85
Landmarks 2.1278325.283811.6518283432.65
Singularities 04.299280.994159143430.7
Average 31.4625


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 2.717871.159430.4318572.931031.9443329
02 0.2679490.006298380.0001832540.259960.14132132
03 0.5197060.03395960.001169750.542220.28561633
04 0.09654950.1556960.2479810.01270470.13118634
05 0.05174870.1710450.003376370.2031560.11037631
06 0000016
07 1.099560.7778290.2191521.468490.94426728
08 0.2756590.0589320.01481250.2920540.17019929
09 0.1484710.3172090.2380480.2238990.23135133
10 0.2728950.9741611.207960.1510880.68316334
11 1.0150.232732.48283e-051.089240.62189328
12 0.2456580.04634070.0680950.2144490.14922533
13 0.04426850.1823480.002031370.2072490.11226434
14 1.44871.248040.6380461.924121.3466629
15 0.726750.8498350.3401871.113940.78652433
16 0.1215340.0007708020.003464160.107120.062742333
17 00.10503800.1047120.055056833
18 3.119663.346350.003777475.703173.2326129
19 0.3415880.03640740.1036760.2675680.1983833
20 0.9378960.7888090.8857420.8293230.8637429
Avg 0.6725730.5245610.2204790.8822750.60354530.65


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.9015798.115896.7036424
02 0.3606981.741211.2269332
03 11.03630.3865653.1670834
04 00.1726720.092700933
05 25.589515.025621.820534
06 0.0125810.323890.20198734
07 11.67555.513038.8103231
08 5.481730.2210512.3695726
09 8.665590.3926013.3182933
10 0.002106821.07860.39968134
11 1.821480.07069780.64962926
12 15.91815.228128.8673534
13 2.329390.1867441.5776634
14 14.79917.2069110.738528
15 1.3427913.98628.2603134
16 5.6244924.887120.261734
17 1.412957.11974.9049334
18 30.023622.534725.490133
19 1.066761.23911.1626834
20 12.286515.013713.972831
Avg 7.517546.52227.1998231.85


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 5.967669.46410.929414.96820.08693.9027736.815717.578628
02 1.567976.0761.680477.3486.077670.99216212.2486.7382432
03 6.131253.1363.304697.1210510.12851.9843218.04888.594733
04 3.267267.557962.9104511.79226.716232.7630314.48199.2163534
05 4.639699.8914.6593812.728712.57392.5033321.001112.652934
06 1.310160.7650.9506252.140072.1209404.052992.1278334
07 5.4759410.0247.5487514.57916.30732.2250930.389315.297331
08 2.88754.276.09759.548148.54738018.82299.0077333
09 4.737316.0627.8203113.060710.42952.2084620.144911.771433
10 4.2117511.1224.8903917.64289.818174.9551223.286213.672134
11 2.37264.3193.003386.470576.528030.71679720.77656.432333
12 5.823184.0323.4427310.5927.431241.3009520.28828.8535934
13 3.261724.31.464845.728216.280211.2514.42696.0262934
14 10.333511.5786.9134822.812714.75952.408435.282118.866630
15 9.1476622.3094.0710932.505219.6098043.333125.283834
16 1.552735.7752.314458.103895.761571.9531215.50036.8858934
17 1.718753.042.167964.582164.96046012.69514.6645434
18 5.5234416.8356.9521514.119626.9810.68359445.405220.550331
19 7.688916.727.0353115.483111.62944.2932528.332313.710434
20 7.901689.8845.1510617.571111.70090.733.75615.105629
Avg 4.776037.8584.6654212.444910.92241.7420223.454411.651832.65


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 5.594783.349732.878795.719774.2992831
02 0.2852610.1665990.18190.2667860.22434333
03 1.347550.02168210.3224080.9954580.65893333
04 0.5429440.5349920.5395770.5364690.53802332
05 0.08056710.1161020.09059870.1068990.098748734
06 0000014
07 1.88281.094570.9083012.103521.5059131
08 0.4339860.4237360.267740.5894860.42861331
09 0.8237650.898610.5326741.192280.86247833
10 2.216531.396831.62941.790621.7100132
11 1.491710.4209280.1796121.592090.88585132
12 0.3617860.1855670.2959230.2332710.26459734
13 0.0116930.0084392900.02036190.010180928
14 2.453011.412691.972171.888871.9305231
15 4.061952.679284.304992.362763.3338734
16 0.027900300.00833170.01503340.011682527
17 00.027562900.03043020.015215128
18 0.5256970.6197010.1469370.9998760.57340631
19 2.346370.1557811.692690.4733691.0830334
20 1.386781.499041.193641.703341.4484931
Avg 1.293750.7505920.8572841.131030.99415930.7


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.