Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for Romeo

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 0.00017100717.81813.95557113430.05
Fissures 028.50716.3666623428.8
Landmarks 0.73341939.007910.1988263431.05
Singularities 00.04959060.0041786612.53021.225
Average 27.7812


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 3.553394.01440.2712086.047993.7823731
02 22.99887.8183314.31115.696815.130333
03 16.99193.670588.3020612.301710.350934
04 0.01316330.05234650.06880340.0029440.036113333
05 7.247230.7985532.923534.91283.9482934
06 00.013921400.01247270.0068279233
07 9.148633.625494.864757.602246.4852831
08 0.6608471.044820.04353981.474760.84769834
09 23.087713.547715.663219.627417.818134
10 0.05153830.0905260.1441310.003588080.074351730
11 3.736882.86330.4312435.375813.2976631
12 1.789680.2768140.6454451.408611.0583434
13 0.006280940.002362814.32663e-050.008069960.0043520326
14 4.332953.556940.2711786.931253.9384330
15 00.002758400.002405980.0013442528
16 00.00092004500.0007884750.0004489211
17 00.00032604900.0003254430.00017100718
18 6.449585.429450.14598410.40155.9411131
19 6.192950.4743722.762854.00023.4634234
20 3.260182.587780.0213625.27962.9259631
Avg 5.476082.493582.543525.054563.9555730.05


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 17.161424.927223.40731
02 5.904474.918225.2856233
03 10.45240.5408533.1286433
04 00016.5
05 0.03095620.01210670.02423133
06 00.01214590.0073897529.5
07 7.8334120.327813.642534
08 10.028913.901712.3234
09 15.12882.942537.2059234
10 00015
11 30.84798.8649116.13434
12 0.002979141.413990.93363632
13 0.5558360.2259870.4401132
14 28.95223.2991715.231831
15 00.0471380.025790329
16 0.3911520.1022930.17165424
17 0.4047150.1846350.27004732
18 26.718129.673328.507134
19 0.5183350.140870.30825533
20 00.4682170.2895112
Avg 7.746585.600156.3666628.8


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 3.3440610.0385.199618.3832117.0442036.39712.800327
02 10.49770.44813.148416.414618.6836.9956927.067917.503433
03 6.735940.5259.4218811.218912.99955.3511519.24212.091434
04 1.007462.659611.490215.49121.471790.4687510.74673.451528
05 4.14750.1685.446886.794417.529972.7057910.86297.1548333
06 0.438750.2550.2620310.7444820.72719503.759360.73341930
07 4.934536.9025.916810.626313.11361.7294626.924111.763728
08 1.98756.8813.1355.7500610.97881.0259124.2878.5736132
09 15.43551.59619.769525.423726.798510.458138.700426.097334
10 1.350283.805841.944967.610171.972930.4687514.15154.7494826
11 3.390455.8383.454965.5177313.00181.2319127.32868.9052434
12 2.861191.4423.628834.732975.841382.1931412.14325.3425933
13 1.093751.0250.6835942.154871.8523309.314911.991533
14 5.871459.2612.8321910.437215.28071.1757428.997612.810529
15 0.4570310.560.3656250.6954491.26505.792061.0143928
16 1.113280.950.7910161.859092.2522305.571852.0635229
17 1.181641.180.7226541.893522.6751406.677052.215233
18 4.3339817.2483.7939514.2423.48242.2084647.739418.861230
19 4.677970.284.560476.746476.959491.6270310.93976.8444633
20 5.4184837.4646.0233629.432452.23128.298567.253439.007934
Avg 4.013925.426324.62968.8083411.80812.2969221.694810.198831.05


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.0002166780.0047291800.005641220.0028206125
02 00.0021836900.002242080.0011210427
03 0.003191537.98235e-050.0031508100.001575425
04 0000014
05 0000013.5
06 0.000214953000.0002167680.00010838430
07 0.003854860.0005990730.0006770590.003919130.002298124
08 0000012.5
09 0.000354057000.0003418460.00017092326
10 0000013.5
11 9.13052e-050.004916245.28582e-050.005589760.0028213126
12 0.00014925200.00013387106.69357e-0530
13 0000013
14 0.004196830.005344420.0001867260.009359670.004773224
15 9.06895e-052.32957e-0500.0001104035.52014e-0526
16 0000013.5
17 0000014
18 0.01554130.02072374.08196e-050.03630220.018171525
19 0000014.5
20 0.07672480.02736270.01644490.08273620.049590628
Avg 0.005231310.003298110.001034350.007322960.0041786621.225


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.