Home  Details  Evaluation  Register  Download  Submit  Results 

Results for Slicer3 Demon

Algorithm Information

PDF describing the algorithm used

Summary Results:

Figures in this table are extracted from the per-category tables shown further down this page

Scores Rankings
Min Max Average Min Max Average
Lung Boundaries 00.305260.0521125113421.35
Fissures 011.78512.3427813.53427.575
Landmarks 010.31563.6401353323.625
Singularities 0.0001784958.417053.21218313433.2
Average 26.4375


Lung Boundary Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 0.0001835040.007189670.007453590.001061820.0036591711
02 0000011
03 3.63566e-05003.58878e-051.88532e-0512
04 0.01251380.001006590.01146900.0057752625
05 0000013
06 0.02897970.0058604500.03226340.017624834
07 0.1233520.3946370.06815960.3895060.2539623
08 0.09918790.01404190.0005168190.1030010.057789726
09 0.0005912810.0023826600.00272130.0014728721
10 0.03867230.008922060.042243500.021267325
11 0.3410350.009731330.0157940.2934890.17454722
12 0.00659504000.006298130.0034053326
13 00.0022983100.002109180.0011309518
14 0.05418330.5483090.3163590.2937270.3052624
15 00.0061291700.005370280.0029799831
16 0.007516180.007025160.0001743780.01268970.0072777429
17 6.02258e-050.00032734200.0003815130.0002003819
18 0.04045370.2025710.07383610.1569450.12107322
19 0000014
20 0.1024380.02670150.09080530.04319810.064807721
Avg 0.04278990.06185670.03134060.06713990.052112521.35


Fissure Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the reference standard for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 10.802712.024311.785126
02 0.0001153130.000136920.0001288730
03 0.3536040.2115860.24866532
04 0.2039050.04663060.1194734
05 00016
06 0.001572620.0192310.012316332
07 2.42564.320883.3067924
08 3.235175.994764.8677129
09 0.08605750.04550420.059845629
10 0.1870860.1762890.18309933
11 7.396680.01040622.4528228
12 00013.5
13 0.7262430.7618610.7387433
14 5.331335.48965.4159819
15 0.2048850.001043650.093358931
16 15.40333.098636.0532532
17 3.237720.009006571.2620633
18 10.49682.324125.5493325
19 0.02319730.0001248840.010356331
20 4.327644.924354.696621
Avg 3.222181.972922.3427827.575


Landmark Results:

All distances are measured in millimetres

Scan Pair Avg Dist AP Avg Dist SI Avg Dist LR Avg Dist Upper Lung Avg Dist Lower Lung Min Dist Max Dist Score
(Avg Dist)
Ranking
01 5.043286.7833.69759.595311.00770.67968827.86410.315626
02 0.1617190.1820.1898440.3863750.45869402.108340.42108811
03 0.3515620.2870.2179690.4763170.84286102.527360.65592422
04 2.553643.250642.329767.258813.552390.4687515.49795.3779432
05 000000005.5
06 0.4570310.4950.5118751.417440.89422405.355461.0825833
07 3.635163.4512.328055.465567.1418038.89386.2490226
08 1.594.1791.892.902617.42841024.78415.3465431
09 0.4101560.3430.3554690.6819330.96296609.712270.81963925
10 3.400195.122223.1972910.99634.63641028.99477.7688731
11 1.025020.9870.8028130.8284883.23531020.41521.9273421
12 00.007000.012727300.70.0075
13 0.6835940.7750.7617191.478481.6351709.678041.5630932
14 5.791293.2622.458138.019848.15419043.28328.0856822
15 0.3726560.3360.3304690.7006080.81832305.792060.76652920
16 1.640623.151.474612.235936.46666025.24674.4359133
17 0.6835920.70.6249981.479841.515406.605251.466629
18 3.814452.7231.982424.873386.63447025.99925.7539223
19 0.2276560.2730.2203130.4860920.69283802.995160.58119519
20 4.062276.6364.4379310.3949.880170.63671933.336410.178226
Avg 1.795192.147091.390563.483873.798540.089257916.48953.6401323.625


Singularity Results:

% Error means the percentage of points checked in the lung volume for which a penalty was incurred

Scan Pair % Error Left Lung % Error Right Lung % Error Upper Lung % Error Lower Lung Score
(% Error Overall)
Ranking
01 7.288127.521577.100827.744847.4228333
02 0.2461130.08234260.0529060.2711710.16203832
03 4.126263.284881.862775.515773.6892734
04 2.195032.575343.123761.736982.4303733
05 00.023489400.0240370.012018532
06 0.2271750.2351660.1773470.2849270.23113734
07 3.574318.576755.088796.843695.9662434
08 2.907783.299082.660763.565063.1129134
09 1.243161.582621.316681.520811.4187434
10 3.651514.692695.534113.055684.2948933
11 4.20971.910441.205874.611652.9087634
12 0.0003109417.07962e-050.0003012115.57798e-050.00017849531
13 1.828031.225260.8281742.267641.5479134
14 5.1678311.63738.680418.153698.4170534
15 0.6770751.328080.2561221.783631.0198832
16 6.586215.990322.2013810.27836.2398333
17 0.3426751.154130.4996571.081560.7906134
18 5.040397.594814.011428.662236.3368334
19 0.1364510.1154660.1043060.1443910.12434932
20 7.466268.651498.697787.537788.1177833
Avg 2.845723.574062.670173.754193.2121833.2


This website is copyright 2009-2010 Keelin Murphy, Bram van Ginneken.